She Chose My Brother. Then She Asked for Her Job Back

Chapter 3

4,746 words

Eileen laughed. The sound carried up the back stairs.

“Is that really the best excuse you could come up with?”

I’d told her exactly what kept me busy. She was so sure she knew what I wanted that she hadn’t bothered to listen.

“The man who runs Apex is about your age,” she went on. “Paige told me even he’d make time for the right woman. If he can manage it, what are you pretending to be so busy with?”

Of course Paige had said that. She’d talked up the job and left my name out, probably thinking she’d get to see the look on both our faces when she introduced us.

A year ago, I would have taken Eileen pulling me into a stairwell as proof that she cared. I’d given everyone years of good reason to think I was hopelessly in love with her. Now that I’d finally lost interest, even the woman who’d built Apex with me thought I’d change my mind by morning.

“Let me make something clear, Russ.” Eileen lifted her chin. “I didn’t want you before, and I’m engaged now. Every time you chase after me, I think a little less of you.”

Her gaze dropped briefly to my mouth.

“Unless you think you’d be happy being the man I keep on the side.”

I used to go home from dinners at Mason House and replay every word she’d said to me. Sometimes I’d lie awake wondering whether I’d made her laugh as hard as Marcus had. I’d spent years trying to be the sort of man she might choose, and here she was, wearing my brother’s ring and asking how much of my dignity I’d give up for an hour alone with her.

I laughed before I could stop myself. Then I opened the stairwell door and walked away. I’d already spent enough of Grandfather’s birthday talking about Eileen Mason.

In the great hall, I took a glass of sparkling wine from a passing tray and sat in a window alcove at the far end. Grandfather was across the room with a group of elders. I decided I’d finish my drink, wish him a happy birthday, and go home.

Someone snapped her fingers beside my ear.

“Well, if it isn’t the eldest Farley son.”

A group of Eileen’s friends crowded into the alcove. Two sat so close their skirts covered the toes of my boots. The others stood in front of me with their glasses raised.

“We were taking bets on whether you’d come,” one of them said. “I thought you’d be too heartbroken.”

“Oh, he’d have come even if he’d known. Look at him. He still thinks he has a chance.”

A hand settled on my thigh. I knocked it away.

“Careful,” the woman said, drawing her hand back with a smile. “A few years at Westmere and he’s too good to touch.”

“He wasn’t too good for us when he needed someone to put in a word with Eileen.”

I remembered that well enough. When we were younger, Marcus could outrun half the pack on four paws, then change back and charm the people he’d beaten into buying him a drink. I’d figured my best chance was to get Eileen’s friends talking about me when he wasn’t in the room.

I knew which books Eileen kept on her nightstand and which mare she liked to ride. I’d made a point of learning what her friends liked, too. Every winter I sent them gifts. A pair of riding gloves from Westmere for one, a first edition for another. One of them once told me that Eileen had called me thoughtful. I’d lived on that single word for a week.

“Eileen’s engaged now,” the woman beside me said. “You were never going to beat Marcus. Surely you’ve worked that out.”

She leaned in until I could smell the sweet perfume at her throat and the wine on her breath.

“Spend one night with us, though, and we might put in a good word. Who knows? We could still get you into her bed.”

I shifted away. Her fingers closed around my jaw.

“Don’t be shy, Russ. We can keep a secret.”

“Oh, Eileen!” one of the women called.

I caught sight of her just beyond the group and started to rise. Hands caught at my sleeves and pulled me back.

“Eileen. Tell your friends to let go of me.”

A couple of them looked at each other. The woman holding my jaw took her hand away. For a moment, I thought the others might follow her lead.

Eileen stopped close enough to hear every word. One of her friends slipped an arm around her waist. Eileen looked straight at me and let the woman steer her away.

“Eileen!”

“Easy, Farley.”

Two of them pinned me against the back of the bench. One tipped the glass in my hand toward my mouth. I turned my face away.

“How do you still not get it?” a woman murmured. “Marcus comes first. Then there’s us. Then there’s her dog. And somewhere below the dog, there’s you.”

I’d been trying to smile it off. That did it.

“Be a good boy and we’ll put in a word for you. She might let you sit at her feet if you ask nicely.”

“That’s right,” another said. “It’ll stay between us.”

I gripped the stem of the glass until my knuckles went white.