The Thirty-Second Stolen Life

Chapter 3

3,952 words

No, I refused to let this go.

I grabbed the handle of my suitcase, marched down the street, and knocked on the door of 16 Locust Lane. Mrs. Jenkins, who had watched me grow up, opened the door.

"Mrs. Jenkins! It's me, Joy!" I clung to her like a lifeline. "Something terrible has happened! My parents are missing, and strangers are occupying our house! Did you see my parents today? Did they—"

"Joy? Honey, are you confused? That's the Lewis family's house. They've lived there for years."

I froze. "Mrs. Jenkins, that's Arthur Miller's house. It's my home! Last month you came over to borrow vinegar. My mom gave you tomatoes from her garden."

"Never happened!" Mrs. Jenkins's voice abruptly spiked in volume. "Young lady, stop making things up! I've never heard of an Arthur Miller in my life!"

With that, she slammed the door right in my face.

I stood shivering in the biting wind, cold settling deep into my bones.

I ran to knock on the doors of house number 15 and house number 18.

The answers were chillingly identical:

"The Millers? Never heard of them."

"Miss, you must have the wrong neighborhood."

"That house has always belonged to the Lewises. We all know them."

Drowning in despair, I spotted elderly Mrs. Cooper heading toward the curb with a bag of trash.

I sprinted toward her, grabbing her arm. "Mrs. Cooper, you know my parents, don't you? Please tell me where they took them!"

Instead of answering, Mrs. Cooper violently jerked her arm away, dropped her trash, and scurried back inside, locking the deadbolt behind her.

I stood alone on the pavement, staring at row after row of dark, tightly locked windows. The entire world felt like it was spinning violently off its axis.

Was I really losing my mind?

Was the sight of my parents welcoming me through the front door just a vivid hallucination?

I stumbled back to the front of 17 Locust Lane. Through the living room window, I watched the seven of them laughing together over dinner.

The little girl pointed at the television, Martha lovingly dished food onto her plate, and Walter poured himself a glass of wine with a gentle chuckle.

It was all so sickeningly warm, so effortless—as if they had lived under that roof for decades.

And there I was: a shattered trespasser, a raving lunatic on the outside looking in.

No. Stop doubting yourself.

I shook my head violently, forcing the paralyzing thoughts out of my mind.

For the next two days, I wandered Locust Lane like a ghost.

I checked into a cheap roadside motel nearby. Every morning before dawn, I crouched across the street, watching that front door like a hawk.

On the third morning, I ambushed Martha as she walked out to buy groceries.

"Give me back my parents!" I blocked her path, my eyes bloodshot and raw.

Martha jumped in fright, but quickly regained her composure. "Miss, why are you still lurking around here? Didn't the police make things clear enough?"

"That cop was dirty! You're all in this together!" I rasped.

"Tell me where my parents are!" I grabbed her forearm with both hands, refusing to let go.

Martha wrenched her arm free with surprising force and screamed at the top of her lungs, "Help! This psycho is attacking me!"

Several neighbors out on morning walks rushed over.

Martha pointed an accusing finger at me. "It's this girl again! She broke into our house on Thanksgiving claiming it belonged to her, and now she's accusing me of kidnapping her parents! The police already came, but she won't stop harassing us!"

The neighbors looked at me. Their eyes were laced with suspicion, pity, but mostly a desperate urge to stay uninvolved.

"Look at her. She's clearly out of her mind."

"So young, too. What a shame."

"Just stay away from her, don't get mixed up in it."

I looked across those familiar faces.

Mr. Davis. Mrs. Peterson. Old Mr. Henderson, who used to slip me butterscotch candies when I was a kid.

Every single one of them looked at me like I was a complete stranger. A dangerous lunatic.